Matthew 26:25
Then Judas, which betrayed him, answered and said, Master, is it I? He said unto him, Thou hast said.
Matthew 26:25
Verse 25 records Judas’ direct response: “Master, is it I?” Jesus replies, “Thou hast said.” The question demonstrates Judas’ attempt to deflect blame or to hide his intent, while Jesus’ reply confirms the truth. The exchange serves to reveal human duplicity and the dynamics of concealment within the inner circle. The concise dialogue heightens dramatic tension and intensifies the climactic turn of events. The disciples’ general act of self-examination contrasts with Judas’ specific, willful resistance to repentance. This moment also reinforces the idea that Jesus knows the human heart and speaks truth with gentleness, even when it pierces.
Theologically, Judas’ question and Jesus’ terse confirmation reveal the seriousness of sin and the inescapability of truth before God. It demonstrates that divine omniscience does not force human response; individuals retain moral agency and responsibility for their choices. The moment foreshadows the ultimate betrayal and the necessity of sacrifice to accomplish salvation. It’s a sobering reminder that not all who are close to Jesus will choose faithfulness, and yet grace remains available to all who turn.
Reflect on honesty with God and with others. Do you hide intentions or mask motives? Invite accountability, naming hidden sins, and seek accountability partners or mentors. Use this as a moment to recommit to integrity in relationships, workplaces, and communities. Remember that even notorious failures can become occasions for grace when confronted with truth and repentance.
Cross-References: John 13:21-30; Psalm 109:4-5; Romans 14:12; Proverbs 28:13