Mark 9:16

**Mark 9:16**

In Mark 9:16, Jesus asks the scribes, “What question ye with them?” immediately after observing a dialog or perhaps a contested moment about his authority or teaching. The setting is tense: scribes argue with Jesus’ companions, likely challenging him or testing his claims. The question is pointed, not casual; it shifts the dynamics from confrontation to a request for clarification. The scribes, trained in the law, often served as legalistic critics in Mark, emphasizing external ritual rather than inner transformation. Jesus’ question exposes the scribes’ posture: they may be interrogating Jesus, but he reads the underlying motive—whether they seek truth or merely trap him. It’s a teachable moment about how to engage with controversial topics: ask clarifying questions, aim for understanding, and avoid quarrels that obscure the point of faith.

This verse underscores a central Markan motif: Jesus as authoritative interpreter of God’s will who calls others to authentic faith, not mere debate. The call to “what question” invites readers to examine motives, ensuring dialogue aims at revelation rather than victory. It also highlights the tension between traditional religious authority (scribes) and the experiential reality of God’s kingdom breaking in through Jesus. Theologically, it emphasizes discernment—knowing when to press, when to listen, and how to press for truth without becoming merely argumentative. It invites believers to pursue truth with humility, recognizing that questions can become pathways to faith if asked in sincerity.

When you engage others about faith, lead with curiosity: ask questions that uncover people’s real concerns rather than winning a quarrel. Examples: “What part of Jesus’ teaching confuses you?” or “What outcome would you want from prayer in this situation?” Such questions open space for genuine dialogue. If you’re in a teaching or Bible study role, invite participants to articulate what they’re hearing and where they doubt. Practice humble defense: present beliefs with scripture and personal experience, but remain teachable. In family life, use sheltered moments of discussion after a sermon or podcast to explore questions together rather than arguing about who’s right. The goal is clarity, trust, and transformation, not dominance in a debate.

Cross-References: Isaiah 1:18; James 1:5; Luke 12:11-12; 1 Corinthians 2:14; Proverbs 18:13